December 1998, Vol. 32, No. 10

 

Focus. . . Cost of Unintentional Injuries to Missouri Children

The patient abstract system indicates a total of 612,880 records for Missourians treated during 1997 in hospitals and outpatient facilities for the effects of injury and poisoning. Of that total, 39,412 (6 percent) were inpatient records, and 573,468 (94 percent) were emergency room or other outpatient records. Records for children under the age of 18 years comprised 195,719 (32 percent) of the total. Of the records for injured children, only 4,185 (2 percent) were records for inpatients, while 191,534 (98 percent) were records for outpatients. The number of patients is somewhat less than the number of records because some patients are readmitted or visit the emergency room more than once.

Injuries are classified in the patient abstract system on the basis of International Classification of Diseases, 9th Revision, Clinical Modification (ICD-9-CM) E-codes. Use of E-codes designates the external cause, or mechanism (e.g.: falls, poisonings, burns) of the injury, as well as a judgment of intent. This includes whether the injury was believed to be unintentional, was the result of assault, was self-inflicted, or was of unknown or some other intent. For children under the age of 18 years, 184,760 (94 percent) of the records had E-codes for unintentional injuries. Inpatient and outpatient records for children with unintentional injuries numbered 3,402 (2 percent) and 181,358 (98 percent), respectively.

The patient abstract system also reports charges imposed by the hospital or outpatient facility. For the 4,185 records of children treated as inpatients, the sum of charges was $54.2 million. Of this total, $46 million (85 percent) of the charges were related to unintentional injuries (Table 1). For the 191,534 records of children treated as outpatients, the sum of charges was $88.3 million. Of this total, $81.4 million (92 percent) of the charges were related to unintentional injuries. Unintentional injuries accounted for more than ninety percent of both the numbers of injuries and the hospital charges for injury to children; therefore, the focus of this report is on those injuries reported as unintentional.

Of the 3,402 unintentional injury records for inpatients, 2,864 (84 percent) were related to just eight different mechanisms. Similarly, of the total 181,358 unintentional injury records for outpatients, 152,633 (84 percent) were due to the eight most frequent mechanisms of injury. Table 2 shows that injuries due to falls and being struck by or against an object or person accounted for about half of all the recorded injuries to children. Motor vehicle crashes ranked fourth after cutting and piercing injuries; however they caused about a third of the most serious injuries, as indicated by their number one ranking for inpatients. Falls also caused serious injury, and were the second most frequent cause of admissions for children. Over all, most of the injuries to children were less serious, as ninety-eight percent of the records were for outpatients.

The combined data from inpatients and outpatients, broken out by type of motor vehicle injury, indicate that 8,664 (54 percent) of motor vehicle injury records resulted from collisions involving two or more vehicles. Non-collision injuries (e.g.: loss of control of vehicle, injury while boarding or alighting) accounted for 3,354 (21 percent). Injuries to pedestrians accounted for 910 (6 percent) of the 16,020 inpatient and outpatient motor vehicle injury records. Pedalcycle injuries caused about half that many at 379 (2 percent).

The most frequent type of fall resulting in reported injury was falls from a higher level (e.g.: playground equipment, embankments, furniture, trees), which made up 27 percent of the total. Falls at the same level (e.g.: slipping, tripping, stumbling) comprised 20 percent of reported fall injuries. Falls on stairs or steps made up 8 percent, while falls resulting from collisions, pushing, or shoving by another person were 6 percent of the total falls. This latter group includes 2,348 (5 percent) records of falls in sports activities, while falls from playground equipment accounted for 3,842 (8 percent) of the total 50,802 inpatient and outpatient fall records.

Injury reports associated with sports and recreation from all mechanisms (e.g.: falls, being struck by or against an object or person, pedalcycles, submersion) totaled 28,234, or 15 percent of the recorded injuries to children, both outpatient and inpatient. (Of these 28,234 reported sports/recreation injuries, 98 percent were treated as outpatients.) The greatest percentage (44 percent) of the reported sports/recreation injuries were in the struck-by category (n=12,333). Other mechanisms of sports/recreation injuries were pedalcycles numbering 7,108 (25 percent), falls numbering 6,332 (22 percent), non-motor vehicle transportation injuries numbering 1,707 (6 percent), motor vehicle traffic injuries totaling 378 (1 percent), and injury as pedestrians not related to motor vehicles numbering 331 (1 percent). Forty-five children (0.2 percent) were injured in submersion or near drowning incidents related to sports or recreation.

The mean length of stay for children admitted for unintentional injury of all types was 4.8 days, with the total statewide being more than sixteen thousand days. Length of stay in outpatient facilities is almost always less than one day, and is not reported here. Inpatient charges for childhood unintentional injury totaled nearly $46 million, with a mean of more than $13 thousand per stay (Table 3). Despite the lower mean charge, total outpatient charges were higher than inpatient charges due to the much greater number of outpatient visits. Outpatient charges totaled $81 million, or 63 percent of all charges.

Table 3 shows the charges assessed by hospitals and outpatient facilities as related to the most frequent causes of injury. Motor vehicle traffic injury stands out as the most costly type of injury, having a total charge of about $32.5 million. The average charges for reported motor vehicle injuries, inpatients and outpatients combined, was $2,033. This was nearly three times greater than the next higher average, that for poisonings, and nearly three times the mean charge for all injuries. The second most costly cause of injury was falls, with total charges of about $28.5 million, and an overall mean of $563. Falls ranked first in total charges for outpatients and second for inpatients. Though the average charge for falls was not high, the great number of falls contributed to their large overall cost.

Burns due to contact with hot objects or substances ranked third among causes for hospital treatment, but did not appear among the most frequent injuries treated in outpatient facilities. Of the total 3,068 reported burn injuries, 187 (6 percent) were treated as inpatients. The severity of the inpatient burn injuries is indicated by their high mean charge of $13,015. Their mean inpatient length of stay was 6.8 days, compared to 4.8 days for all inpatient injuries.

Charges related to injuries associated with sports and recreation from all mechanisms (e.g.: being struck by or against an object or person, falls, pedalcycles) totaled $20.1 million, or 16 percent of total charges for injuries to children, both outpatient and inpatient. (Of this $20.1 million charge for sports/recreation injuries, 73 percent were outpatient charges.) The greatest percentage (32 percent) of the reported sports/recreation charges was in the struck-by category. Other mechanisms of sports/recreation injuries having high total charges were falls (24 percent), pedalcycle injuries (24 percent), and non-motor vehicle transportation injuries (13 percent).

In Missouri in 1997, hospitals and outpatient care facilities charged about $127.4 million for treatment and care of unintentional childhood injuries. Motor vehicle injuries are among the most serious causes of unintentional injury because of the relatively high incidence as well as the severity, as indicated by the high mean charge for care. Records of injury due to falls are more than three times greater in number than motor vehicle injury records, but the total charge for falls injuries is twelve percent less than for motor vehicle injuries, indicating their lesser severity. About sixteen percent of the total charges for treatment of unintentional injuries to children were related to sports or recreation.

Injuries are the leading cause of death in the United States from the first year of life to age 44. Unintentional injury to children is a major source of medical costs as well as suffering and disability. Until recent years the incidence of injury to children has generally been taken for granted, with the assumption that they occur by chance and are therefore not preventable. But it is recognized now that the occurrence of injuries to children is largely determined by characteristics of the environment, personal behavior, and the products used in their work, play, recreation and travel. Most injuries can be prevented.

 

Table 1

Missouri Children Under 18 Treated for Injuries, 1997

Intent by Charges by Patient Status

 

INPATIENTS
Charges (dollars)

OUTPATIENTS
Charges (dollars)

TOTAL
Charges (dollars)

Intent

Number

Mean

Sum

(1,000s)

Number

Mean

Sum

(1,000s)

Number

Mean

Sum

(1,000s)

Unintentional

3,402

13,520

45,995

181,358

449

81,408

184,760

690

127,403

Assault

174

12,410

2,159

5,139

549

2,820

5,313

637

4,979

Self Inflicted

376

5,127

1,928

899

1,067

960

1,275

2,265

2,888

Undetermined & other

233

17,681

4,120

4,138

747

3,090

4,371

1,650

7,210

TOTAL

4,185

12,951

54,202

191,534

461

88,278

195,719

728

142,480

 

Table 2

Missouri Children Under 18 Treated for Unintentional Injuries, 1997

Major Causes by Patient Status

INPATIENTS

OUTPATIENTS

TOTAL

 

Mechanism

 

Freq.

Percent of

Total

 

Mechanism

 

Freq.

Percent of

Total

 

Mechanism

 

Freq.

Percent of

Total

Motor vehicle traffic

1,076

31.6

Fall

50,085

27.6

Fall

50,802

27.5

Fall

717

21.1

Struck by/against

38,705

21.3

Struck by/against

38,940

21.1

Struck by/against

235

6.9

Cut/pierce

17,266

9.5

Cut/pierce

17,358

9.4

Poisoning

229

6.7

Motor vehicle traffic

14,944

8.2

Motor vehicle traffic

16,020

8.7

Burn (hot object/subst.)

187

5.5

Overexertion

11,350

6.3

Overexertion

11,395

6.2

Transport(not MV)

161

4.7

Natural/environm

9,918

5.5

Natural/environm

10,038

5.4

Pedalcycle (not MV)

139

4.1

Pedalcycle (not MV)

6,969

3.8

Pedalcycle (not MV)

7,108

3.8

Natural/environm

120

3.5

Poisoning

3,396

1.9

Poisoning

3,625

2.0

Other

538

15.8

Other

28,725

15.8

Other

29,474

16.0

TOTAL

3,402

100.0

TOTAL

181,358

100.0

TOTAL

184,760

100.0

 

 

Table 3

Missouri Children Under 18 Treated for Unintentional Injuries, 1997

Mechanism by Charge for Services by Patient Status

INPATIENTS

Charges (dollars)

Mechanism

Mean

Sum

(1,000s)

Motor vehicle traffic

20,309

21,852

Fall

8,433

6,046

Burn (hot obj/subst)

13,015

2,434

Transport (not MV)

11,827

1,904

Struck by/against

6,619

1,556

Pedalcycle (not MV)

8,691

1,208

Poisoning

3,854

883

Natural/environm

5,609

673

Other

17,546

9,440

TOTAL

13,524

45,995

OUTPATIENTS

Charges (dollars)

Mechanism

Mean

Sum

(1,000s)

Fall

450

22,504

Struck by/against

376

14,548

Motor vehicle traffic

716

10,682

Cut/pierce

345

5,947

Overexertion

494

5,608

Pedalcycle (not MV)

511

3,560

Natural/environm

257

2,540

Poisoning

500

1,696

Other

499

14,324

TOTAL

450

81,408

TOTAL

Charges (dollars)

Mechanism

Mean

Sum

(1,000s)

Motor vehicle traffic

2,033

32,534

Fall

563

28,551

Struck by/against

414

16,104

Cut/pierce

385

6,676

Overexertion

521

5,939

Pedalcycle (not MV)

671

4,768

Natural/environm

321

3,213

Poisoning

712

2,578

Other

544

100,362

TOTAL

691

127,403

 

Provisional Vital Statistics for October 1998

Live births increased in October as 6,728 Missouri babies were born compared with 5,920 in October 1997. Cumulative births for the 10- and 12-month periods ending with October also show increases, although birth rate for January-October remained the same, 13.9 per 1,000 population.

Deaths increased slightly in October, but decreased for the cumulative 10- and 12-month periods ending with October. For January-October, deaths decreased by 2.4 percent from 45,650 to 44,545.

The Natural increase for Missouri in October was 2,298 (6,728 births minus 4,430 deaths). The natural increase rose for all three time periods shown below.

Marriages increased in October, but decreased for the cumulative 10- and 12-month periods ending with October.

Dissolutions of marriage decreased in October, but increased for the 10- and 12-month periods ending with October. The marriage to divorce ratio decreased from 1.75 to 1.66 for the 12 months ending with October.

Infant deaths decreased in October, but increased for the cumulative 10- and 12-month periods ending with October. The infant death rate for January-October increased from 7.8 to 8.1 per 1,000 live births.

PROVISIONAL RESIDENT VITAL STATISTICS FOR THE STATE OF MISSOURI

October

Jan. Oct. cumulative

12 months ending with October

Item

Number

Rate*

Number

Rate*

Number

 

Rate*

 

 

1997

1998

1997

1998

1997

1998

1997

1998

1997

1998

1996

1997

1998

Live Births

5,920

6,728

13.3

15.6

62,233

62,716

13.9

13.9

71,695

75,064

13.9

13.3

13.8

Deaths

4,385

4,430

9.9

10.2

45,650

44,545

10.2

9.9

54,477

53,733

10.1

10.1

9.9

Natural increase

1,535

2,298

3.5

5.3

16,583

18,171

3.7

4.0

17,218

21,331

3.8

3.2

3.9

Marriages

4,184

4,522

9.4

10.5

38,150

36,910

8.5

8.2

44,483

42,572

8.3

8.2

7.8

Dissolutions

2,268

2,078

5.1

4.8

21,355

21,442

4.8

4.8

25,483

25,707

4.8

4.7

4.7

Infant deaths

58

48

9.8

7.1

483

508

7.8

8.1

581

593

7.6

8.1

7.9

Population base (in thousands)

...

...

5,402

5,440

...

...

5,402

5,440

...

...

5,358

5,395

5,433

*Rates for live births, deaths, natural increase, marriages and dissolutions are computed on the number per 1000 estimated population. The infant death rate is based on the number of infant deaths per 1000 live births. Rates are adjusted to account for varying lengths of monthly reporting periods.

AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY/AFFIRMATIVE ACTION EMPLOYER Services provided on a nondiscriminatory basis.

Alternate forms of this publication for persons with disabilities may be obtained by contacting the Missouri Department of Health, Center for Health Information Management & Epidemiology/Bureau of Health Data Analysis, P.O. Box 570, Jefferson City, MO 65102; phone (573) 751-6278. Hearing impaired citizens telephone 1-800-735-2966.